Symphony in D Minor

This early Symphony in D Minor was written in 1869.
It is sometimes referred to as "Die Nullte" or Symphony No. "0". For many years, it was thought that this symphony pre-dated the Symphony No 1, but it is now known that the work was composed between the First and Second Symphonies. Bruckner never considered it to be part of his canon of symphonies but it is telling that he never destroyed it.

Notes by Jose Marques

Paul Hawkshaw's Essay on the Date of the Symphony in D Minor

Timed Analysis by William Carragan

Symphony in D Minor
1869 Ed. David Chapman [2023]

Ballot, Remy

Altomonte Orchestra Saint Florian

19/8/23: Gramola CD set 99311

51:35

18:07

14:27

7:25

11:36

Symphony in D Minor
1869 Ed. Leopold Nowak [1968]

Asahina, Takashi

Osaka Philharmonic Orchestra

5/6/1978: JVC CD VICC 40190-99 (full set) .

41:07

13:14

11:40

6:24

9:49

5/6/1978: JVC CD VICC 60281-91 (full set)

41:07

13:14

11:40

6:24

9:49

5/6/1978: JVC LP 9523

41:07

13:14

11:40

6:24

9:49

5/6/1978: Tower Records SACD Set GCAC-1018-20

41:07

13:14

11:40

6:24

9:49

Asahina, Takashi

Osaka Philharmonic Orchestra

8/10/1981: Takashi Asahina Society CD TAS-002

39:00

12:23

10:43

6:18

9:15

Asahina, Takashi

Sapporo Symphony Orchestra

21/5/82: Tower/Fontec SACD TWFS 90007

41:37

13:29

11:17

7:05

9:46

Asahina, Takashi

Tokyo Metropolitan Symphony Orchestra

12/5/1982: Fontec CD FOCD 9230

43:00

13:32

12:45

6:19

10:02

Barenboim, Daniel

Chicago Symphony Orchestra

3/1979: DG CD 159327

45:48

15:12

12:43

6:49

11:04

3/1979: DG CD 429 025-2 (full set)

45:48

15:12

12:43

6:49

11:04

3/1979: DG CD 437250

45:48

15:12

12:43

6:49

11:04

3/1979: DG LP 2531 319

45:48

15:12

12:43

6:49

11:04

3/1979: DG LP 2740 253 (full set)

45:48

15:12

12:43

6:49

11:04

Bellak, Richard

White Mountain (NH) Festival Orchestra

1974: RCB NewClassic RCBCD002

9:22

Blunier, Stefan

Beethoven Orchestra Bonn

25-27/5/10: MDG SACD 937 1673-6

50:11

18:08

14:51

7:01

10:07

Bolton, Ivor

Mozarteum Orchestra

6-7/10/18: Berlin Classics CD 03030050BC

46:25

15:47

13:55

6:40

10:03

Bosch, Marcus

Aachen Symphony Orchestra

26and28/5/12: Coviello Classics SACD COV 31315

41:23

14:06

11:45

6:25

9:07

26and28/5/12: Coviello Classics SACD Set 31215

41:23

14:06

11:45

6:25

9:07

Chailly, Riccardo

RSO Berlin

2/1988: Decca/London CD 421-593-2

46:24

15:15

13:47

6:47

10:35

2/1988: Musical Heritage Soc CD 514794X

46:24

15:15

13:47

6:47

10:35

Cohen, Warren

MusicaNova Orchestra

1/4/19: MusicaNova CD

9:58

1/4/19: MusicaNova DVD

9:58

Cohen, Warren

MusicaNova Orchestra

31/3/19: MusicaNova CD

39:44

11:39

11:14

6:49

9:50

31/3/19: MusicaNova DVD

39:44

11:39

11:14

6:49

9:50

Davies, Dennis Russell

Bruckner Orchestra Linz

23/11/08: Sony Box Set 889854833725

47:02

16:30

12:37

6:57

10:38

Davies, Dennis Russell

Linz Bruckner Orchestra

23/11/08: Arte Nova 88697 74975 2

47:02

16:30

12:37

6:57

10:38

Fairfax, Bryan

Polyphonia Orchestra of London

: Lanta Fe CD LF-435

43:00

12:06

13:28

6:58

10:24

Fischer, Ivan

Concertgebouw Orchestra of Amsterdam

15/12/05: Koninkijk Concertgebouworkewst 3 (Download)

42:24

15:14

11:12

6:19

9:36

Frontini, Roberto

Luebeck Youth Orchestra

14/10/00: Orchestra CD

47:15

15:52

13:01

6:41

11:42

Gelmini, Hortense von

Nuremberg Symphony

1975: Colosseum LP SM 558

41:18

13:35

10:05

7:21

10:17

1975: Klassic Haus Restorations KHCD 2012-007

41:18

13:35

10:05

7:21

10:17

Guschlbauer, Theodor

Bruckner Orchestra Linz

6/7/1981: Amadeo ARVS 501

43:06

13:43

12:05

7:15

10:03

6/7/1981: Camerata CD 25CM257

43:06

13:43

12:05

7:15

10:03

6/7/1981: Camerata CD 641 257 2

43:06

13:43

12:05

7:15

10:03

6/7/1981: ORF-Oberoesterreich CDT-1022

43:06

13:43

12:05

7:15

10:03

Inbal, Eliahu

Frankfurt Radio Symphony Orchestra

1/1990: Teldec CD 0630-14194-2

44:06

15:06

12:47

6:13

10:00

1/1990: Teldec CD 2292-46330-2

44:06

15:06

12:47

6:13

10:00

1/1990: Teldec CD 419427

44:06

15:06

12:47

6:13

10:00

1/1990: Ultima CD 0927 41398 2

44:06

15:06

12:47

6:13

10:00

Jarvi, Paavo

Frankfurt Radio Symphony Orchestra

23-24/3/17: RCA Hybrid SACD SICC 10430

45:07

14:38

11:54

8:09

10:24

23-24/3/17: RCA Hybrid SACD SICC 10430

45:07

14:38

11:54

8:09

10:24

23-24/3/17: RCA SACD Set SICC 10331-40

45:07

14:38

11:54

8:09

10:24

Komatsu, Kazuhiko

Bruckner Orchestra Nagoya

12/6/05: Voicelle CD BON-020-21

48:15

15:44

14:15

6:36

11:29

Lallot, Remy

Altomonte Orchestra Saint Florian

19/8/2023: Gramola CD GRAM 99306

51:35

18:07

14:27

7:25

11:36

Lee, Dong-Ho

Jeju Philharmonic Orchestra

14/2/08: Jeju Philharmonic CD JPO 083

44:50

13:57

12:45

6:48

11:07

Lizzio, Alberto

Philharmonia Slavonica

: ZYX CD CLS 4138

43:45

14:46

10:59

6:47

11:11

Maazel, Lorin

Bavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra

9-20/1/99: Bavarian Radio Set

48:48

18:25

11:39

7:54

10:49

9-20/1/99: BR Klassik Set 900711

48:48

18:25

11:39

7:54

10:49

9-20/1/99: Von-Z S-2-226/7

48:48

18:25

11:39

7:54

10:49

Maerzendorfer, Ernst

ORF Symphony Orchestra

13/1/72: Adventure Classic MJ 26368

43:44

14:20

11:00

7:14

11:10

13/1/72: Classical Excellence LP CE 11022.

43:44

14:20

11:00

7:14

11:10

13/1/72: ZYX CD CAB-CD 10325

43:44

14:20

11:00

7:14

11:10

13/1/72: ZYX CD CLA 10053

43:44

14:20

11:00

7:14

11:10

13/1/72: ZYX CD CLS 4333

43:44

14:20

11:00

7:14

11:10

13/1/72: ZYX CD MVD 1013-2

43:44

14:20

11:00

7:14

11:10

Maier, Richard

Schwaebisches Jugendsinfonieorchester

1985: Iton LP IT 30148

10:19

Maier, Richard

Schwaebisches Youth Symphony Orchestra

1970s: Iton LP IT-30148

10:19

Marriner, Neville

SWR Symphony Orchestra of Stuttgart

1993: Laserlight CD 14 091

44:50

15:22

12:04

7:25

9:59

Mehta, Zubin

Israel Philharmonic Orchestra

7/1989: Newton Classics CD 8802143

41:43

14:47

11:11

6:38

8:50

7/1989: Sony CD 45864

41:43

14:47

11:11

6:38

8:50

7/1989: Sony SB2K 87743

41:43

14:47

11:11

6:38

8:50

Minkowski, Marc

Swedish Radio Symphony Orchestra

5/12/08: Dirigent DIR-0157

44:45

15:04

12:45

5:46

10:58

Nelsons, Andris

Leipzig Gewandhaus Orchestra

12/2020: DGG CD Set 486 4528

47:40

16:28

13:49

7:06

10:17

12/2020: DGG SACD Set UCGG 9219/28

47:40

16:28

13:49

7:06

10:17

Paternostro, Roberto

Wuerttemberg Philharmonie Reutlingen

24/6/06: Antes Edition SCH.3112 (Complete set)

47:34

15:51

13:10

7:16

10:56

24/6/06: Membran Music Ltd. 232766 (Complete set)

47:34

15:51

13:10

7:16

10:56

Poschner, Markus

Bruckner Orchestra Linz

22-24/2/21: Capriccio CD C8082

44:29

13:55

11:48

8:10

10:36

Rozhdestvensky, Gennadi

USSR Ministry of Culture Orchestra

1983: Centurion Classics 10 CD Set ECC 10018

1983: Centurion Classics 10 CD Set ECC 10028

1983: Chant du Monde CD 2LDC-278.851/52

44:31

15:07

12:47

6:52

9:45

1983: Chant du Monde LP LDX 78.851/52

44:31

15:07

12:47

6:52

9:45

1983: Essential Media 894231577727

44:51

15:13

12:50

7:00

9:45

1983: GPR CD GPR-004

44:31

15:07

12:47

6:52

9:45

1983: High Definition Tape Transfers

44:53

15:13

12:49

6:58

9:53

1983: JapanBMG/Melodiya CD BVCX38013/14

45:02

15:11

12:50

6:54

9:46

1983: Klassic Haus Restorations KHCD 2012-009

45:02

15:11

12:50

6:54

9:46

1983: Melodiya LP C10 21617 004

44:31

15:07

12:47

6:52

9:45

1983: Venezia CDVE 04240 (boxed set)

1983: Venezia CDVE 04368 (boxed set)

Schaller, Gerd

Philharmonie Festiva

3/2015: Profil PH 15035

43:29

15:33

11:30

6:29

9:53

Shimono, Tatsuya

Osaka Philharmonic Orchestra

17/11/05: Avex Classics SACD AVCL-25099

54:00

16:43

15:39

9:19

12:01

Skrowaczewski, Stanislaw

Frankfurt Radio Symphony Orchestra

1981: En Larmes ELS 01-145/6

44:45

14:33

12:40

7:11

10:16

Skrowaczewski, Stanislaw

Saarland Radio Symphony Orchestra

22-25/3/99: Arte Nova CD 74321-75510

44:55

13:53

13:21

6:44

10:56

22-25/3/99: Briliant Classics Set 92084

44:55

13:53

13:21

6:44

10:56

22-25/3/99: Briliant Classics Set 94707

44:55

13:53

13:21

6:44

10:56

22-25/3/99: Oehms Classics CD OC 209

44:55

13:53

13:21

6:44

10:56

Skrowaczewski, Stanislaw

Yomiuri Nippon Symphony Orchestra

8/10/14: Denon CD COGQ-75

45:08

14:21

13:15

6:35

10:57

Solti, Georg

Chicago Symphony Orchestra

10/1995: London/Decca CD 4521602 and full set

38:13

12:38

10:26

6:01

8:48

10/1995: Universal Classics (Japan) UCCD 3729

Thielemann, Christian

Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra

27-28/3/21: Sony (Japan) CD SICC-30891

47:15

16:45

13:39

7:08

10:15

27-28/3/21: Sony Boxed CD Set 19658760172

46:52

16:21

13:29

7:01

10:01

27-28/3/21: Sony Boxed SACD Set SICC 10437

46:52

16:21

13:29

7:01

10:01

27-28/3/21: Unitel Blu Ray Set 809 604

47:15

16:45

13:39

7:08

10:15

27-28/3/21: Unitel Blu-Ray 806804

47:15

16:45

13:39

7:08

10:15

27-28/3/21: Unitel DVD 806708

47:15

16:45

13:39

7:08

10:15

Tintner, Georg

National Symphony Orchestra of Ireland

23-25/9/96: Naxos CD 8.554215/6

47:35

14:32

14:29

7:14

11:10

23-25/9/96: Naxos CD Set 8.501101

47:35

14:32

14:29

7:14

11:10

23-25/9/96: Naxos CD Set 8.501104

47:35

14:32

14:29

7:14

11:10

23-25/9/96: Naxos CD Set 8.501205

47:35

14:32

14:29

7:14

11:10

Venzago, Mario

Indianapolis Symphony Orchestra

9-10/1/04: ISO Transcription CD

46:30

15:12

13:58

7:24

11:10

Venzago, Mario

Tapiola Sinfonietta

11/2010: CPO 550 023-2 (Set)

44:00

14:41

12:16

7:07

9:52

11/2010: CPO 777 617-2

44:00

14:41

12:16

7:07

9:52

Vis, Lucas

Southwest German Radio Symphony Orchestra

22-23/4/77: En Larmes ELS-17-1036

42:15

14:17

12:00

6:11

9:37

Young, Simone

Hamburg Philharmonic Orchestra

20-21/5/12: Oehms Classics CD OC 026 (Set)

49:41

16:58

13:39

7:43

11:18

20-21/5/12: Oehms Classics SACD OC 685

49:41

16:58

13:39

7:43

11:18

Symphony in D Minor
1869 Ed. Woess. published by Universal Edition [1924]

Beinum, Edward van

Concertgebouw Orchestra

13/3/55: Archipel ARPCD 0672 (Download only)

41:35

13:09

11:29

5:39

11:18

13/3/55: Disco Archivia CD DA-042

41:00

12:12

11:20

5:20

10:56

13/3/55: Haydn House CD SDA 2005

41:00

12:12

11:20

5:40

10:56

13/3/55: SOMM CD Ariadne 5027-2

41:17

12:59

11:31

5:40

11:07

13/3/55: Vibrato CD VHL-240

41:00

12:12

11:20

5:40

10:56

Bongartz, Heinz

Dresden Philharmonic

12/11/50: Archipel ARPCD 0672 (Download only)

48:29

15:59

13:19

6:37

12:34

Haitink, Bernard

Concertgebouw Orchestra

4-7/7/66: High Definition Tape Transfers HDDL396 24/192

43:47

14:27

13:01

6:33

9:46

4-7/7/66: Philips CD 442 040-2 (full set)

43:47

14:27

13:01

6:33

9:46

4-7/7/66: Philips CD 4756740 full set

43:47

14:27

13:01

6:33

9:46

4-7/7/66: Philips Club Edition LP 66 011

43:47

14:27

13:01

6:33

9:46

4-7/7/66: Philips LP 802 724 LY and full set.

43:47

14:27

13:01

6:33

9:46

4-7/7/66: Philips LP PHS900-131

43:47

14:27

13:01

6:33

9:46

4-7/7/66: Philips LP SAL 3602

43:47

14:27

13:01

6:33

9:46

Leitner, Ferdinand

Bavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra

11/6/1960: Orfeo CD 269921

47:12

14:48

13:55

7:20

11:09

Matacic, Lovro von

Philharmonia Orchestra

Jan-56: Angel LP 3548B

6:45

Jan-56: EMI CD S 68739 2

6:45

Spruit, Henk

Concert Hall Symphony Orchestra

1952: Bearac CD BRC 3381

42:23

13:09

12:03

6:00

11:11

1952: Concert Hall LP CHS 1142

42:00

13:01

11:57

5:54

11:08

1952: Forgotten Records FR 708

42:27

13:09

12:03

6:00

11:11

1952: Klassic Haus Restorations CD GSC 010

42:23

13:09

12:03

6:00

11:11

1952: Musical Masterpiece Society LP M-1142

42:00

13:01

11:57

5:54

11:08

1952: Nixa LP CLP 1142

42:00

13:01

11:57

5:54

11:08

Zaun, Fritz

Staatskapelle Berlin

Oct-33: Abruckner.com BSVD-0101